| I can only imagine | PN 1997.2 I23 2018 | 488 |
| Iceman Murder Mystery | GN 776.22. .I8 I24 2011 | 341 |
| Identity | PN 1997.2 .I34 2003 | 454 |
| Identity Thief | PN 1995.9 .C55 I34 2013 | 413 |
| If Beale Street Could Talk | PN 1997.2 .I5 2019 | 538 |
| Imitation Game | QA 29 .T8 I65 2015 | 492 |
| Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks | RC 265.6 .L24 C66 | 514 |
| Impossible The | PN 1997.2 .I47 2013 | 408 |
| In Memoriam: New York City 9/11/01 | HV 6432.7 I5 2002 | 375 |
| In Search of Shakespeare | PR 2894.I5 | 405 |
| Inherit the wind / | PS3523.A934 I63 2001 (D37) | 37 |
| Inside a recording studio | TK7881.4 .I57 2008 (D256) | 256 |
| Interstellar | PN 1995.9 .S26 I68 2015 | 494 |
| Into the arms of strangers: stories of the Kindertransport | DS135.G3315 I586 2001 (D15) | 15 |
| Into the woods | PN1995.9.M86 I685 1999 (D131) | 131 |
| Intruder | PN 1997.2 .I587 2019 | 582 |
| Investing in caring relationships | HQ778.5 .I581 2003 (D124) | 124 |
| Iran's Young Rebels | DS 318.82 .I73 2011 | 365 |
| Iron Jawed Angels | PN 1997.2.I76 2004 | 275 |
| Islam: Empire of Faith | BP 50 .I85 2009 | 392 |
| Ivanhoe | PR 5318 .A1 1997 | 385 |
